Google "aspect ratio calculator" to get real dimensions of tire sizes. As far as tire construction?...I'm sure a lower profile tire has a stiffer sidewall. As far as whether it matters?...well obviously opinions are everywhere. Hell's Gate is without question a tire-test and a half! But, I think if you ask that guy in the black H2T how pleasant his 600 mile interstate drive was just to get there...you'de get plenty of points for the 20"s. I also think that Hell's Gate climb works out to .00000000001% of his total mileage. Everybody has different requirements for what they want out of their rigs. But in the case of tires, you got to ask yourself a few questions...
Is this tiny percentage of extreme use worthy of a $2000-plus decision on tires?
Can I handle the "sissy" comments from the bystanders for ten-minutes of climibing Hell's Gate?
Will my wife look at me in disgust when she compares other guy's tires to mine?
Will I have to scream to carry-on a conversation at high-way speeds?
My point is...forum discussions like this always seem to jump to the furthest extreme of the spectrum. Its very easy to loose sight of your rig and how you intend to use it. You'll never see anybody posting a photo of their H3 with the cruise control set at 65mph, with a cheese platter sitting on the console and Mozart playing in the background. As much as hard core guys don't like to admit it...that's certainly a valid argument. I wheel my H3 as much as anybody, and I still demand excellent on-road performance, mileage, and noise levels. Tires are not cheap, and more than likely...you will not be happy with your choice, in all categories. Compromise is everything, and its never been so true as it is when choosing tires. Don't get caught up in the testosterone game...think about how you use your H3, and select the tires accordingly.