I can tell you that the EMPI are based on the first issue half-shafts, and..... they are too short IMHO. They can work as a trail spare to allow you to limp home, but when you level the 3 with a T Bar adjustment, the full extended length of the half-shaft becomes crucial.
The EMPIs cut it too close if you ask me. If I was miles from home and actually had to do a trail swap using the EMPI, I would back off the T Bar bolt to lower the nose for the ride home.
So if your looking only for a trail spare, you should consider the EMPI. If your question is for a true replacement, I wouldn't do it.
Personally, if I go through the tear down and R&R a half-shaft, I'm gonna buy another trail spare and not redo the job over when I get home with yet another OEM shaft.