This is starting to sound like the presidential debate. There needs to be some fact checks.
1 incident of unexplained cracks in a set of tires from a manufacturer that produces several name branded tires that forum users have used and had good service out of sort of sounds like this is an isolated case and suspect that the supplier's dated stock or failure to inspect the tires before shipping or mounting procedure were an issue.
I know that still sucks for TeleMike.
I got what I really wanted when I bought the MT/MTZ back in 06 and was pleased to an extent with the STT until they were well worn. They are the same carcass made by the same company as the ST/MAXX but different tread designs. Now what I really want for driving 10,000 or 12,000 miles a year on pavement and rough gravel and dirt only roads as opposed to several hundred rock crawling and occasionally deep mud and water is a 10 ply tire with reinforced sidewall, siping for wet pavement ice and snow and slick rock and a more open deep tread than most AT, but with more rubber on the road or rocks than a more open worn mud lug tire with lots of voids and less contact with the road surface or rocks.
Lack of noise was a side benefit and surprising to me in a 10 ply tire that still has an open tread design on the ST/MAXX. When I drive 10-12 hours a day sometimes for two days both directions on the pavement to go to offroad destinations the lack of noise and vibrations that MT tires develop is welcomed.
Yeah I can do the loud roar tires since it is a truck but it is a personal decision based on trying different tires for the average of all types of driving that I do.
I do not frequently drive in what I used to consider muddin in the gumbo but do on occasion.
It comes down to individual requirements and cautious buyers. I researched these ST/MAXX and found two local tire dealers that regularly stock them for farmers, Hunters, contractors in the building trade and oil and gas industry needing multi-purpose tires.
Time will tell as I have yet to have time to go muddin but from the loose gravel river bed I played in they seem to have great traction to the point I had to be careful not to dig myself in. Aired down they would utilize the strong side wall for more flotation.
Interesting discussion of tires and lots of personal opinions.
Got Mudd?