Back in 2005, when I was in a GM Brand Quality Engineering meeting I submitted a suggestion to add the cast iron front diff to all adventure series (off-road package) vehciles. GM's Brand Quality Axle engineer, explained that there was an $85.00 difference between the aluminum and the cast iron diff. (This was a discussion that I brought up due to having some people I know blowing diffs in Utah...I won't mention who!:giggle

At that time, 85 bucks was considered too much to add to the cost of the vehicle...remember, GM was broke. I was told that the gears in future models would be hardened to a new spec to stop the gear failure due to weak gears, but this still left the stretching case a problem.
Warranty figures when I left GM in 2008 indicated there were (approx.) 1100 front diffs were repaired or replaced and this was based on 2006-2008 vehicle warranty coverage repair/replacement. Understand that number has gone up since I left and that last warranty report would have been run the first week in October, since I retired on Oct 31.
And this warranty number included the same vehicle having two diffs fail. And in most cases, the first repair was internal gears, second replacement was complete carrier assembly. My thoughts were that the case was damaged due to stress in the first scenario, but the tech could not identify any problems with the case (if they even tried to identify a problem); thus, down the road the case itself failed and the second repair required a complete carrier assembly (case) replacement.
I know a few people who had the internal gears replaced during a first repair, and the entire assembly replaced a few thousand miles later. However, GM's warranty procedures were to replace the broken items only. (NOTE: This was no different than Ford, Chrysler, BMW or Toyota, and probaby true for all other manufactures but cannot speak for them.)