Ha, ha!! Well, I've been somewhat impressed with the mileage I've gotten. Tracking my fuel economy for the last month and a half, here's what it looks like: 18.4, 16.8, 17.6, 18.2 (mpg). Same station, same pump, 87 Octane, Top Tier Fuel, 70/30 (highway/city miles).
Here are some other vehicles I have or have owned:
Dodge Ram 5.7 Hemi 4x4 16.5mpg.
Jeep Grand Cherokee 4.7 16.8.
Jeep Grand Cherokee 4.0 (6-cyl), 17.5
The Jeeps are lighter, and the Dodge Hemi has a lot more power but also cylinder de-activation (which doesn't seem to yield a lot more economy). Given the weight and aerodynamic nature of the vehicle, the H3 mileage is better than I expected. It's all about how much energy does it take to move a certain amt of mass. And there's a fair amt of mass with these H3's.
OTOH, I had a Jetta diesel which turned in a solid 39-40 mpg every single fill-up!