Maybe you guys can help me, this seems like the right thread and ongoing discussion. I've been looking into tuners lately and not sure if selecting one over another really matters in my case. I don't see myself ever going larger than 37" tires (no re-gearing), and I doubt I'd do any engine mods beyond intake, headers and cat-back exhaust. They pretty much all do the same thing, and while some may be better able to adjust for more engine mods or even larger tires I don't know if there are other differences in tuners I should care about. This will only ever be used on one vehicle so multi-vehicle support isn't an issue.
Superchips Flashpaq (couple different models I've found, perhaps some are just older OOP versions?)
Hypertech Max Energy or Max Energy E-Con (are they even different?)
Edge Evolution CS
DiabloSport inTune
SCT Performance x4
Jet Performance Programmer
I just want to plug the tuner in, select an appropriate tune, perhaps try a couple different ones such as 87 vs 91 octane, adjust speedo if/when I move to 37" tires, change shift firmness and shift points, and be able to go back to stock if needed. I don't want to leave it hooked up, although and instant MPG display might be interesting until I get a feel for how speed affects mpg. Is there really any difference between these for my needs other than cost and cosmetics? I tried to limit the list to sub $400 street price units, with the Edge being slightly more, but if stepping up a bit is going to give superior results I'm open to suggestions.